WHAT I LEARNED READING FOR CONTESTS THIS YEAR: Part the Second, Incomprehensible Screenplays



Another issue that made many of the incomprehensible screenplays, well… incomprehensible to read and understand was overwritten narrative.  Now, I’m not talking about people who like to be a tad proesy here and there (I will talk about that later).  
No, I am talking about narrative so dense (how dense was it?)…it was so dense it was like reading a novel; and not just any novel, no, no such luck.  It made me feel as if I was reading something Proust and Faulkner might write. 
It was so dense, I felt like I was hacking my way through a jungle with a machete. 
It was so dense, I felt like I was a cat hacking up a fur ball.
It was so dense, that the next thing I expected to happen was the big bang.
Okay, I’m exaggerating.  Except, sadly, I’m really not.  And on top of it, whenever anybody would write in this manner, they would add insult to injury by employing lengthy paragraphs that would come in multiples of five or more.  I mean, it’s one thing to stab someone in the back; but to take the knife and then twist it around seven times?  Give a guy a break, already.
And let’s face it.  Narrative written in this style is not just plain difficult to read in its own right.  This much narrative, more often than not, is filled with unnecessary detail that gets in the way of the necessary detail to such a degree that it’s difficult for a reader to even know what’s important and what’s not as he reads. 
And it’s often filled with metaphors and other literary flourishes that require one to stop and figure out what the frack the author is even trying to say (if a reader has to go to the dictionary or google a phrase more than a few times in a screenplay, you may need to start rethinking your style; but if a reader has to do research three or four times per page, you are in real trouble).
And if there is too much of this type of narrative, then the plot and characters are no longer illuminated, but are buried and crushed until it’s very difficult if not almost impossible to tell what is going on, robbing your story of forward momentum and tension.
This is at times compounded by writers who write like directors, story boarding the screenplay, including all sorts of camera angles and explanations for shots, transitions, and exactly how certain scenes should be framed.   It’s compounded by writers who like to tell actors how to say their lines and interpret their characters while blocking their every move; writers who want to describe a set in minute detail and likes to chose the colors and style of everything their characters wear; writers who want to choose every background song or piece of music and let the reader know where it starts and stops. 
And then just imagine if you had all of that alongside a plot that is convoluted and a story that is complicated and hard to follow.  At that point the whole thing just becomes one big slough of despair. 
But these are the extremes, though as I said, I’ve never had so many extremities in one year.  My next essay will be on those who just overwrite, but not to the degree of incomprehension.
NEXT: Narrative and formatting
Advertisements

2 Comments

So tell me what you think.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s